The New York knowledge graph has 1,067,994 cases and 2,986,301 citations; the most cited case is People v. Contes (10,486 citations).

New York knowledge graph

As of , data through , built .

Change state

Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming. All states.

New York knowledge graph

The map needs JavaScript. Without it, its figures are in the tables here.

Map of every New York case

Every New York case and the citations between them
Area
Color
TodayCases decided after the chosen year fade, and overruled flags and later treatment show only what had been said by then.
New York opinion in the corpusCited onlyOverruledCitation not found

Scroll to zoom · drag to pan · click a section to load every case in it · Tab, Enter and Escape work too
Loading the map of New York case law…

How to read the map

Size. A cell's area follows how many New York cases cite it. With Area set to PageRank, it follows how much of the citation network leads to it, so a case cited by heavily cited cases grows. Either way, area is a count, not a measure of authority: a routine procedural citation counts as much as a landmark holding.

Color. Status shows whether the opinion's text is in the corpus, whether a later opinion said in words that it overruled the case, and citations that match no case. Court gives each court its own color. Citation group colors cases that cite each other more than they cite the rest of the graph; it is a statistical grouping, not a subject index. Later treatment colors each case by what later New York opinions said about it in words.

Lines. Select a case to draw what it cites (blue) and the most-cited cases that cite it (orange). Red marks an authority a later opinion said was overruled or treated negatively, and amber outlines mark the authorities it cites that themselves cite one.

Treatment.

Overruled. A later opinion said in words that it overruled or disapproved the case. A missing flag proves nothing: the scan finds only what an opinion said in words.

As of a year. Move the year control to see the map as it stood then. Cases decided later fade, their lines are left out, and the overruled flags and later treatment show only what had been said by that year.

Not found. The citation appears in New York opinions but in no case table on file. It may be a miscitation repeated in the citing opinions, or a case outside the corpus. It is not a finding that the case does not exist.

Cases since 2019.

Finding a case. Type a reporter citation, a party name or a docket number. A link to the state page ending in #case= and the case's record number opens the map on that case.

Keyboard. Tab moves through the courts on the map. Enter zooms into the court in focus, then into a section, then selects a case. Escape closes the case and goes back up a level. Plus and minus zoom, and the zero key fits the whole map.

How it loads. The map opens with the cases big enough to see. Zoom into a section and every case in it loads; select a case and what it cites, the most-cited cases that cite it and its treatment load with it.

How it was built.

Overruled authorities

For each of these, a later opinion said in words that it overruled or disapproved it. "Cited after" counts the New York cases decided in a later year than the overruling that still cite it. Some cite it only to say it was overruled, so read each one before relying on the count. A missing flag proves nothing: the scan finds only what an opinion said in words.

Loading…

Who cites a case and what later opinions said about it, with dates. Search every state.

Jump to: later treatment · leading cases by court · what New York courts cite most. Built from the open New York caselaw set and CourtListener's citation table. Method.

Later treatment

What later New York opinions said about the cases they cite, in words.

Overruled or disapproved
442

a later opinion says so in words

Questioned or limited
252

a later opinion questions it

None found
1,067,300

not a finding of good law

Of 1,067,994 cases, through . Each label is read from the citing sentence; each case page names the opinions behind it.

Treatment labels report what later opinions said in words; they do not read your facts or say whether a case binds a court.

Built from the caselaw set.

Treatment as of any date, for many citations at once: validity records in the Legal AI API.

Leading cases by court

Each New York court's most-cited decisions, by the number of New York cases citing them.

CourtCaseCitationDecidedCited by
New York Court of AppealsPeople v. Contes60 N.Y.2d 62010,486
People v. Bleakley69 N.Y.2d 49010,323
People v. Danielson9 N.Y.3d 3428,439
Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New YorkPeople v. Suitte90 A.D.2d 808,155
People v. Paige54 A.D.2d 6315,366
People v. Saunders52 A.D.2d 8333,914
Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New YorkTyroler v. Gummersbach28 Misc. 15156
Great Wall Acupuncture, P.C. v. GEICO Insurance26 Misc. 3d 2337
EBM Medical Health Care, P.C. v. Republic Western Insurance38 Misc. 3d 133
New York Court of ChanceryDavoue v. Fanning2 Johns. Ch. 25119
Gillespie v. Moon2 Johns. Ch. 58518
Field v. Schieffelin7 Johns. Ch. 15017
Court Of Oyer And Terminer New YorkPattison v. Hull9 Cow. 74714
People v. Whipple9 Cow. 7079
People v. Shall9 Cow. 7783

Each case page links its record on CourtListener.

What New York courts cite most

Authorities outside New York (the U.S. Supreme Court, federal courts, other states), by how many New York cases cite them.

CitationCaseGroupCited by
386 U.S. 738Anders v. CaliforniaU.S. Supreme Court10,195
463 U.S. 745Jones v. BarnesU.S. Supreme Court3,560
466 U.S. 668Strickland v. WashingtonU.S. Supreme Court1,663
41 N.Y.2d 759People v. ProchiloNew York, cited but not in the corpus1,534
34 N.Y.3d 545People v. ThomasNew York, cited but not in the corpus1,453
384 U.S. 436Miranda v. ArizonaU.S. Supreme Court1,364
476 U.S. 79Batson v. KentuckyU.S. Supreme Court1,116
67 N.Y.2d 650New York, cited but not in the corpus1,051
373 U.S. 83Brady v. MarylandU.S. Supreme Court798
81 N.Y.2d 884New York, cited but not in the corpus744
91 N.Y.2d 976New York, cited but not in the corpus715
445 U.S. 573Payton v. New YorkU.S. Supreme Court554
97 N.Y.2d 678New York, cited but not in the corpus480
76 A.D.3d 144Mixon v. TBV, Inc.Other courts, cited452
72 N.Y.2d 918New York, cited but not in the corpus444
500 U.S. 352Hernandez v. New YorkU.S. Supreme Court439
392 U.S. 1Terry v. OhioU.S. Supreme Court417
388 U.S. 218United States v. WadeU.S. Supreme Court396
65 N.Y.2d 449Kaufman v. Eli Lilly & Co.New York, cited but not in the corpus387
378 U.S. 108Aguilar v. TexasU.S. Supreme Court381
541 U.S. 36Crawford v. WashingtonU.S. Supreme Court378
41 N.Y.2d 296People v. BraceyNew York, cited but not in the corpus375
395 U.S. 238Boykin v. AlabamaU.S. Supreme Court368
371 U.S. 471Wong Sun v. United StatesU.S. Supreme Court353
393 U.S. 410Spinelli v. United StatesU.S. Supreme Court336

Most-cited statutes and rules: U.S. Const. art. I (116); U.S. Const. art. IV (46); U.S. Const. art. VI (27); 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (9); U.S. Const. art. III (7); U.S. Const. art. II (6); 28 U.S.C. § 2412 (5); 8 U.S.C. § 1101 (4). The full list is below.

Built from the caselaw set.

Citation groups, labeled

The largest groups of New York authorities that cite each other more than they cite the rest of the graph, each with a short label for the area of law its leading cases share.

GroupLabelConfidenceCases and statutes
1summary judgmenthigh87,697
2administrative law, judicial reviewhigh71,178
3negligence, premises liabilitymedium69,967
5criminal procedure, guilty pleashigh32,365
6child custodyhigh26,661
7res judicata, collateral estoppelhigh24,280
8civil procedure, motion practicehigh21,177
9trusts and estateshigh20,425
10family law, divorcehigh18,681
11insurance coveragehigh14,794
12negligence, master and servanthigh14,394
13extraordinary writs, prohibitionmedium13,948
14prisoner rights, disciplinary proceedingshigh13,470
15discovery procedurehigh12,771
16criminal appeal, assigned counselhigh11,312
17criminal procedure, speedy trialhigh10,979
18workers compensationhigh10,169
19arbitration, collective bargaininghigh9,037
20municipal claims, noticehigh9,006
21attorney disciplinehigh7,568
22sex offender registration, risk levelhigh6,273
23serious injury, no-faulthigh5,821
24unemployment insurance benefitshigh4,791
25ineffective assistance of counselhigh3,907
26attorney lienshigh3,832

Labels are written by software from each group's fifteen most important cases and their holdings; each word of a label appears in those cases' names, holdings, statutes or frequent words. A group is a statistical grouping by citation, not a subject index. Built from the caselaw set.

Graph size

Cases, citations and the newest decision in the graph.

Cases in the graph
1,067,994

904,269 with opinion text in the corpus

Citations between them
2,986,301

each citing case counted once

Citations read
3,725,187

from 965,138 opinions

Citations found
79.3%

share found in the citation table

Ambiguous, left out
282,219

a page shared by several cases, no name to tell them apart

Decisions through
2026-09-29

newest decision date in the corpus

An edge means the opinion's text cites that authority. It does not mean the opinion relied on, followed or agreed with it.

An overruled flag means a later New York opinion said in words that it overruled or disapproved the case; the absence of a flag proves nothing.

Built from the caselaw set.

Most-cited cases

The hundred cases cited by the most New York opinions, each citing case counted once.

RankCitationCaseDecidedCourt or groupCited by
160 N.Y.2d 620People v. ContesNew York Court of Appeals10,486
269 N.Y.2d 490People v. BleakleyNew York Court of Appeals10,323
3386 U.S. 738Anders v. CaliforniaU.S. Supreme Court10,195
49 N.Y.3d 342People v. DanielsonNew York Court of Appeals8,439
590 A.D.2d 80People v. SuitteAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York8,155
649 N.Y.2d 557Zuckerman v. City of New YorkNew York Court of Appeals6,826
768 N.Y.2d 320Alvarez v. Prospect HospitalNew York Court of Appeals5,788
847 N.Y.2d 606People v. GonzalezNew York Court of Appeals5,469
954 A.D.2d 631People v. PaigeAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York5,366
1036 N.Y.2d 230People v. CrimminsNew York Court of Appeals5,247
1164 N.Y.2d 851Winegrad v. New York University Medical CenterNew York Court of Appeals5,080
1254 N.Y.2d 137People v. BaldiNew York Court of Appeals5,036
1352 A.D.2d 833People v. SaundersAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York3,914
146 N.Y.3d 248People v. LopezNew York Court of Appeals3,905
1539 N.Y.2d 241In re AhoNew York Court of Appeals3,816
167 N.Y.3d 633People v. RomeroNew York Court of Appeals3,807
17463 U.S. 745Jones v. BarnesU.S. Supreme Court3,560
1891 N.Y.2d 708People v. BeneventoNew York Court of Appeals3,340
1934 N.Y.2d 222Pell v. Board of EducationNew York Court of Appeals3,098
2086 N.Y.2d 10People v. GrayNew York Court of Appeals2,787
212 N.Y.3d 277People v. StultzNew York Court of Appeals2,782
2284 N.Y.2d 83Leon v. MartinezNew York Court of Appeals2,613
232 N.Y.3d 383People v. MateoNew York Court of Appeals2,601
2471 N.Y.2d 662People v. LopezNew York Court of Appeals2,600
2579 N.Y.2d 955Gaddy v. EylerNew York Court of Appeals2,510
2698 N.Y.2d 345Toure v. Avis Rent a Car Systems, Inc.New York Court of Appeals2,482
2756 N.Y.2d 167Eschbach v. EschbachNew York Court of Appeals2,300
2845 N.Y.2d 176300 Gramatan Avenue Associates v. State Division of Human RightsNew York Court of Appeals2,161
29176 N.Y. 84People v. . GaimariNew York Court of Appeals1,974
3044 A.D.2d 86People v. GarafoloAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York1,773
31466 U.S. 668Strickland v. WashingtonU.S. Supreme Court1,663
3274 N.Y.2d 1People v. SeabergNew York Court of Appeals1,646
3340 N.Y.2d 210People v. De BourNew York Court of Appeals1,644
3423 N.Y.3d 841People v. GillottiNew York Court of Appeals1,615
3589 A.D.3d 252In re Giovanni S.Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York1,599
3671 A.D.2d 38People v. CrawfordAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York1,556
3741 N.Y.2d 759People v. ProchiloNew York, cited but not in the corpus1,534
38113 A.D.2d 129Nicastro v. ParkAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York1,529
3945 N.Y.2d 493Cohen v. Hallmark Cards, Inc.New York Court of Appeals1,513
4071 N.Y.2d 705People v. RiveraNew York Court of Appeals1,508
4191 N.Y.2d 733People v. HidalgoNew York Court of Appeals1,498
4234 N.Y.2d 371People v. SandovalNew York Court of Appeals1,463
4334 N.Y.3d 545People v. ThomasNew York, cited but not in the corpus1,453
4461 N.Y.2d 9People v. HarrisNew York Court of Appeals1,432
4567 N.Y.2d 836Gordon v. American Museum of Natural HistoryNew York Court of Appeals1,427
4611 N.Y.3d 484People v. HawkinsNew York Court of Appeals1,423
4750 N.Y.2d 707Hearst Corp. v. ClyneNew York Court of Appeals1,379
4811 N.Y.2d 317Lanza v. WagnerNew York Court of Appeals1,371
49384 U.S. 436Miranda v. ArizonaU.S. Supreme Court1,364
5054 N.Y.2d 396People v. GallowayNew York Court of Appeals1,273
515 N.Y.3d 143People v. CabanNew York Court of Appeals1,256
52168 N.Y. 264People v. . MolineuxNew York Court of Appeals1,229
5318 N.Y.3d 257People v. BradshawNew York Court of Appeals1,203
5481 N.Y.2d 494Ross v. Curtis-Palmer Hydro-Electric Co.New York Court of Appeals1,119
55476 U.S. 79Batson v. KentuckyU.S. Supreme Court1,116
56146 A.D.2d 245People v. UdzinskiAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York1,108
5780 N.Y.2d 273People v. CallahanNew York Court of Appeals1,099
5867 N.Y.2d 650New York, cited but not in the corpus1,051
59113 A.D.2d 979People v. CruwysAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York1,036
6060 N.Y.2d 492Northern Westchester Professional Park Associates v. Town of BedfordNew York Court of Appeals1,012
6139 N.Y.2d 105People v. AshwalNew York Court of Appeals1,011
62202 A.D.2d 984Ciesinski v. Town of AuroraAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York1,004
6343 N.Y.2d 268Guggenheimer v. GinzburgNew York Court of Appeals988
6463 N.Y.2d 136In Re the Guardianship of Star Leslie W.New York Court of Appeals975
6560 N.Y.2d 636People v. PellegrinoNew York Court of Appeals969
6686 N.Y.2d 744Lolik v. Big v. Supermarkets, Inc.New York Court of Appeals950
6752 N.Y.2d 302People v. FarrarNew York Court of Appeals936
6871 N.Y.2d 233People v. AlvinoNew York Court of Appeals924
6995 N.Y.2d 633People v. StokesNew York Court of Appeals901
7086 N.Y.2d 397People v. FordNew York Court of Appeals897
7151 N.Y.2d 308Derdiarian v. Felix Contracting Corp.New York Court of Appeals885
72101 A.D.2d 816People v. KazepisAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York859
7340 N.Y.2d 233Basso v. MillerNew York Court of Appeals857
7462 N.Y.2d 755People v. MaliziaNew York Court of Appeals833
7575 N.Y.2d 327People v. ChippNew York Court of Appeals825
7698 N.Y.2d 136Espinal v. Melville Snow Contractors, Inc.New York Court of Appeals819
7757 N.Y.2d 61People v. GloverNew York Court of Appeals810
789 N.Y.2d 286People v. RosarioNew York Court of Appeals806
79373 U.S. 83Brady v. MarylandU.S. Supreme Court798
8068 N.Y.2d 424People v. GonzalezNew York Court of Appeals797
8198 N.Y.2d 314Goshen v. Mutual Life InsuranceNew York Court of Appeals782
8277 N.Y.2d 157W.W.W. Associates, Inc. v. GiancontieriNew York Court of Appeals772
8355 N.Y.2d 89Friederwitzer v. FriederwitzerNew York Court of Appeals746
8470 N.Y.2d 436Berenhaus v. WardNew York Court of Appeals744
8581 N.Y.2d 884New York, cited but not in the corpus744
8666 N.Y.2d 796People v. SatterfieldNew York Court of Appeals736
87184 A.D.2d 114People v. D'AlessandroAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York734
8889 A.D.3d 112People v. WyattAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York734
8937 N.Y.2d 442People v. TaranovichNew York Court of Appeals726
9025 N.Y.2d 585People v. YuklNew York Court of Appeals723
91236 A.D.2d 133People v. OverleeAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York716
9291 N.Y.2d 976New York, cited but not in the corpus715
9325 N.Y.3d 337The People v. Rasaun SandersNew York Court of Appeals706
9464 N.Y.2d 224Hallock v. StateNew York Court of Appeals692
9560 N.Y.2d 539Parochial Bus Systems, Inc. v. Board of EducationNew York Court of Appeals683
963 N.Y.3d 357Nicholson v. ScoppettaNew York Court of Appeals679
9792 N.Y.2d 825People v. LococoNew York Court of Appeals675
9840 N.Y.2d 633Rovello v. Orofino Realty Co.New York Court of Appeals660
9953 N.Y.2d 12Legal Aid Society of Sullivan County, Inc. v. ScheinmanNew York Court of Appeals656
10087 N.Y.2d 727MATTER OF TROPEA v. TropeaNew York Court of Appeals647

Built from the caselaw set; each case links its record on CourtListener.

Most-citing courts

Each New York court's opinions in the corpus, by citations made.

CourtCasesCitations madeMedian per caseTimes its cases are cited
Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York755,8502,618,15611,418,457
New York Court of Appeals120,094278,0610940,136
Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York24,26688,354210,094
New York Court of Chancery3,8741,39001,739
Court Of Oyer And Terminer New York185340076

Built from the caselaw set.

Citation depth by decade

Cases by decade decided: how many authorities each cites, how old they are and where they come from.

DecadeCasesMedian citations found in the textMedian citesMedian cites, opinions over 5,000 charactersShort orders, under 2,000 characters90th percentileMedian age of cited case, yearsCite the U.S. Supreme CourtCite other courtsMedian times citedResolved by
1710s100100%00.0%0.0%0
1800s7600166%1-520.0%11.8%0table 50%, citation only 50%
1810s34700137%21.2%33.7%0citation only 92%, table 8%
1820s53100031%2-173.2%23.9%0citation only 62%, table 37%, other 1%
1830s1,13200021%10.9%11.3%0citation only 66%, table 32%, other 2%
1840s2,22100041%1-51.3%19.7%0table 53%, citation only 46%, other 0%
1850s1,86811215%605.7%54.8%2table 65%, citation only 33%, other 2%
1860s2,6532227%765.1%53.3%1table 72%, citation only 26%, other 3%
1870s5,91211337%683.5%31.9%1table 79%, citation only 17%, pin page 3%, other 1%
1880s7,05200353%5103.9%22.0%0table 80%, citation only 13%, pin page 5%, other 2%
1890s24,53810350%6103.9%19.0%0table 84%, citation only 10%, pin page 4%, other 2%
1900s56,22600364%482.2%10.8%0table 90%, citation only 6%, pin page 3%, other 1%
1910s65,99100378%3102.2%7.2%0table 94%, citation only 3%, other 3%
1920s53,04800484%2142.5%5.2%0table 95%, citation only 3%, other 2%
1930s59,55000587%2152.2%3.8%0table 96%, name 2%, other 2%
1940s38,95600686%3152.4%4.5%0table 93%, name 4%, citation only 3%, other 0%
1950s38,69900781%4192.6%7.2%0table 89%, citation only 6%, name 5%, other 0%
1960s42,81900676%4184.0%5.5%0table 92%, citation only 4%, name 4%, other 0%
1970s45,41511660%678.1%5.0%0table 86%, name 10%, citation only 3%, other 0%
1980s66,52132749%9511.2%3.9%1table 79%, name 15%, citation only 6%, other 0%
1990s102,37633956%968.2%2.1%1table 76%, name 15%, citation only 9%, other 0%
2000s108,707431054%1177.5%4.2%1table 73%, name 18%, citation only 9%, other 0%
2010s128,120541242%1477.3%13.8%0table 77%, name 12%, citation only 11%, other 0%
2020s51,510761011%17117.4%61.8%0table 63%, citation only 31%, name 6%, other 0%

"Median cites" counts the authorities in the graph each case cites; "Citations found in the text" counts citation strings, so a case printed in two reporters counts twice there. Short orders that cite nothing pull the medians down, so the table also gives the median for opinions over 5,000 characters.

Spot check of this build: 298 of 300 citations confirmed against the printed name, citation or docket (99.3%). Wrong citations: 0 of the 200 most cited and 0 of 500 random cases, against 0 of 200 and 0 of 500 in the graph it replaced.

Built from the caselaw set.

Citations by method

Each citation and the method that found its case.

MethodCitationsShare
Reporter citation in CourtListener's table2,290,15976.7%
Citation only, no case found349,58711.7%
Shared page decided by the printed name336,57711.3%
Pin page6,9600.2%
Parallel citation learned from the corpus2,2260.1%
Statute or rule4300.0%
Short form2070.0%
Case name, court and year980.0%
Westlaw or Lexis citation570.0%

Built from the caselaw set.

How often cases are cited

Cases in the corpus by the number of New York cases that cite them.

Cited byCases
0578,641
180,892
2 to 4117,484
5 to 972,651
10 to 4950,765
50 to 992,412
100 or more1,424

Built from the caselaw set.

Most-cited statutes and rules

Statutes and rules by the number of New York cases citing them.

Statute or ruleCited by
U.S. Const. art. I116
U.S. Const. art. IV46
U.S. Const. art. VI27
42 U.S.C. § 19839
U.S. Const. art. III7
U.S. Const. art. II6
28 U.S.C. § 24125
8 U.S.C. § 11014
11 U.S.C. § 294
42 U.S.C. § 19814
18 U.S.C. § 19614
U.S. Const. amend. VI3
U.S. Const. amend. V3
18 U.S.C. § 22513
18 U.S.C. § 22523

Built from the caselaw set.

Method

Built from 965,138 opinions: 2,593,893 citations went to one case in the citation table and 456 to statutes and rules.

Change since the previous build (2026-11-13, extractor precedent-1.7): +2,296 nodes, +13,540 edges.

Each step is on the method page. The citation table is CourtListener's citations file.

Data

How to cite this graph, and its terms.

2,000 case pages (list), all under the site terms. Cite as: Repleader, https://repleader.net/precedent/ny/, data through . Agents: the free MCP tools answer the same questions.

All states: state knowledge graphs.

Related: federal civil filings in New York, citation lookup, how the site counts, corrections, the data API.

Built from the caselaw set and CourtListener's citation table.