The West Virginia knowledge graph has 125,427 cases and 385,106 citations; the most cited case is In Re Cecil T. (2,466 citations).

West Virginia knowledge graph

As of , data through , built .

Change state

Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, Wisconsin, Wyoming. All states.

West Virginia knowledge graph

The map needs JavaScript. Without it, its figures are in the tables here.

Map of every West Virginia case

Every West Virginia case and the citations between them
Area
Color
TodayCases decided after the chosen year fade, and overruled flags and later treatment show only what had been said by then.
West Virginia opinion in the corpusCited onlyOverruledCitation not found

Scroll to zoom · drag to pan · click a section to load every case in it · Tab, Enter and Escape work too
Loading the map of West Virginia case law…

How to read the map

Size. A cell's area follows how many West Virginia cases cite it. With Area set to PageRank, it follows how much of the citation network leads to it, so a case cited by heavily cited cases grows. Either way, area is a count, not a measure of authority: a routine procedural citation counts as much as a landmark holding.

Color. Status shows whether the opinion's text is in the corpus, whether a later opinion said in words that it overruled the case, and citations that match no case. Court gives each court its own color. Citation group colors cases that cite each other more than they cite the rest of the graph; it is a statistical grouping, not a subject index. Later treatment colors each case by what later West Virginia opinions said about it in words.

Lines. Select a case to draw what it cites (blue) and the most-cited cases that cite it (orange). Red marks an authority a later opinion said was overruled or treated negatively, and amber outlines mark the authorities it cites that themselves cite one.

Treatment.

Overruled. A later opinion said in words that it overruled or disapproved the case. A missing flag proves nothing: the scan finds only what an opinion said in words.

As of a year. Move the year control to see the map as it stood then. Cases decided later fade, their lines are left out, and the overruled flags and later treatment show only what had been said by that year.

Not found. The citation appears in West Virginia opinions but in no case table on file. It may be a miscitation repeated in the citing opinions, or a case outside the corpus. It is not a finding that the case does not exist.

Cases since 2019.

Finding a case. Type a reporter citation, a party name or a docket number. A link to the state page ending in #case= and the case's record number opens the map on that case.

Keyboard. Tab moves through the courts on the map. Enter zooms into the court in focus, then into a section, then selects a case. Escape closes the case and goes back up a level. Plus and minus zoom, and the zero key fits the whole map.

How it loads. The map opens with the cases big enough to see. Zoom into a section and every case in it loads; select a case and what it cites, the most-cited cases that cite it and its treatment load with it.

How it was built.

Overruled authorities

For each of these, a later opinion said in words that it overruled or disapproved it. "Cited after" counts the West Virginia cases decided in a later year than the overruling that still cite it. Some cite it only to say it was overruled, so read each one before relying on the count. A missing flag proves nothing: the scan finds only what an opinion said in words.

Loading…

Who cites a case and what later opinions said about it, with dates. Search every state.

Jump to: later treatment · leading cases by court · what West Virginia courts cite most. Built from the open West Virginia caselaw set and CourtListener's citation table. Method.

Later treatment

What later West Virginia opinions said about the cases they cite, in words.

Overruled or disapproved
546

a later opinion says so in words

Questioned or limited
397

a later opinion questions it

None found
124,484

not a finding of good law

Of 125,427 cases, through . Each label is read from the citing sentence; each case page names the opinions behind it.

Treatment labels report what later opinions said in words; they do not read your facts or say whether a case binds a court.

Built from the caselaw set.

Treatment as of any date, for many citations at once: validity records in the Legal AI API.

Leading cases by court

Each West Virginia court's most-cited decisions, by the number of West Virginia cases citing them.

CourtCaseCitationDecidedCited by
West Virginia Supreme CourtIn Re Cecil T.717 S.E.2d 8732,466
State v. Edward Charles L.398 S.E.2d 1232,389
In Interest of Tiffany Marie S.470 S.E.2d 1772,342
Intermediate Court of Appeals of West VirginiaDavid Duff, II v. Kanawha County Commission882 S.E.2d 916173
Blackhawk Mining, LLC v. Harris Argabright915 S.E.2d 726
Curtis F. Perry v. Troy Ravenscroft2024 WL 500299117

Each case page links its record on CourtListener.

What West Virginia courts cite most

Authorities outside West Virginia (the U.S. Supreme Court, federal courts, other states), by how many West Virginia cases cite them.

CitationCaseGroupCited by
466 U.S. 668Strickland v. WashingtonU.S. Supreme Court445
905 S.E.2d 528Syl. Pt. 2, Duff v. Kanawha Cnty. Comm’nOther courts, cited401
250 W. Va. 510Syl. Pt. 2, Duff v. Kanawha Cnty. Comm’nWest Virginia, cited but not in the corpus378
384 U.S. 436Miranda v. ArizonaU.S. Supreme Court273
902 S.E.2d 185Syl. Pt. 2, Christopher P. v. Amanda C.Other courts, cited252
250 W. Va. 53Syl. Pt. 2, Christopher P. v. Amanda C.West Virginia, cited but not in the corpus250
373 U.S. 83Brady v. MarylandU.S. Supreme Court147
879 S.E.2d 779Moore v. ICG Tygart Valley, LLCOther courts, cited141
927 F.2d 955United States v. DunkelFederal courts136
247 W. Va. 292Moore v. ICG Tygart Valley, LLCWest Virginia, cited but not in the corpus127
477 U.S. 242Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.U.S. Supreme Court105
355 U.S. 41Conley v. GibsonU.S. Supreme Court96
400 U.S. 25North Carolina v. AlfordU.S. Supreme Court86
284 U.S. 299Blockburger v. United StatesU.S. Supreme Court75
854 S.E.2d 870Mountaineer Fire & Rescue Equip., LLC v. City Nat’l Bank of W. Va.Other courts, cited65
541 U.S. 36Crawford v. WashingtonU.S. Supreme Court63
244 W. Va. 508Mountaineer Fire & Rescue Equip., LLC v. City Nat’l Bank of W. Va.West Virginia, cited but not in the corpus58
887 S.E.2d 2552004). Amanda C. v. Christopher P.Other courts, cited58
386 U.S. 18Chapman v. CaliforniaU.S. Supreme Court54
470 U.S. 564Anderson v. City of Bessemer CityU.S. Supreme Court53
2024 WL 1715166Syl. Pt. 3, Duff v. Kanawha Cnty. Comm’nOther courts, cited53
509 U.S. 579Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc.U.S. Supreme Court52
424 U.S. 319Mathews v. EldridgeU.S. Supreme Court50
132 S. Ct. 1201Marmet Health Care Ctr., Inc. v. BrownU.S. Supreme Court47
825 S.E.2d 758State v. SitesOther courts, cited46

Most-cited statutes and rules: 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (112); U.S. Const. amend. V (91); U.S. Const. amend. XIV (89); U.S. Const. amend. VI (73); 9 U.S.C. § 2 (49); U.S. Const. art. I (44); U.S. Const. amend. IV (39); 9 U.S.C. § 1 (35). The full list is below.

Built from the caselaw set.

Citation groups, labeled

The largest groups of West Virginia authorities that cite each other more than they cite the rest of the graph, each with a short label for the area of law its leading cases share.

GroupLabelConfidenceCases and statutes
1criminal procedure, appellate reviewhigh17,470
2statutory interpretationhigh16,209
4summary judgmenthigh12,317
5child custody, neglecthigh5,211
6easements, proofmedium3,178
7legal ethics, disciplinehigh3,087
8workers compensation benefitshigh2,840
9wills, testator intentmedium2,463
10family law, divorcehigh2,382
11tax assessmenthigh2,029
13civil procedure, default judgmentsmedium1,931
14election law, ballotshigh1,740
15products liabilitymedium1,589
16contract law, arbitrationhigh1,546
17administrative law, license revocationhigh1,274
18public utility regulationhigh1,259
19surety bonds, judgmenthigh1,043
20negotiable instruments, bank liabilityhigh848
21contracts, agencymedium847
22class actionsmedium750
23unemployment compensation benefitshigh705
24malicious prosecutionhigh647
25insurance policyhigh619
26banking law, receivershipmedium596
27family law, paternityhigh558

Labels are written by software from each group's fifteen most important cases and their holdings; each word of a label appears in those cases' names, holdings, statutes or frequent words. A group is a statistical grouping by citation, not a subject index. Built from the caselaw set.

Graph size

Cases, citations and the newest decision in the graph.

Cases in the graph
125,427

34,362 with opinion text in the corpus

Citations between them
385,106

each citing case counted once

Citations read
780,453

from 39,779 opinions

Citations found
92.5%

share found in the citation table

Ambiguous, left out
24,765

a page shared by several cases, no name to tell them apart

Decisions through
2026-09-29

newest decision date in the corpus

An edge means the opinion's text cites that authority. It does not mean the opinion relied on, followed or agreed with it.

An overruled flag means a later West Virginia opinion said in words that it overruled or disapproved the case; the absence of a flag proves nothing.

Built from the caselaw set.

Most-cited cases

The hundred cases cited by the most West Virginia opinions, each citing case counted once.

RankCitationCaseDecidedCourt or groupCited by
1717 S.E.2d 873In Re Cecil T.West Virginia Supreme Court2,466
2398 S.E.2d 123State v. Edward Charles L.West Virginia Supreme Court2,389
3470 S.E.2d 177In Interest of Tiffany Marie S.West Virginia Supreme Court2,342
4773 S.E.2d 20In Re K.H.West Virginia Supreme Court1,912
5742 S.E.2d 419Melinda H. v. William R., IIWest Virginia Supreme Court1,682
6624 S.E.2d 761State v. BRANDON B.West Virginia Supreme Court1,674
7164 W. Va. 496In re R.J.M.West Virginia Supreme Court1,205
8192 W. Va. 189Painter v. PeavyWest Virginia Supreme Court1,170
9712 S.E.2d 55In Re Kristin Y.West Virginia Supreme Court1,065
10461 S.E.2d 163State v. GuthrieWest Virginia Supreme Court973
11194 W. Va. 3State v. MillerWest Virginia Supreme Court873
12148 W. Va. 160Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. v. Federal Insurance Co. of New YorkWest Virginia Supreme Court811
13633 S.E.2d 771Mathena v. HainesWest Virginia Supreme Court768
14198 W. Va. 79In Re Katie S.West Virginia Supreme Court743
15459 S.E.2d 415Chrystal R.M. v. Charlie A.L.West Virginia Supreme Court730
16196 W. Va. 294State v. LaRockWest Virginia Supreme Court700
17743 S.E.2d 352In Re: Timber M. & Reuben M.West Virginia Supreme Court637
18194 W. Va. 770State Ex Rel. McGraw v. Scott Runyan Pontiac-Buick, Inc.West Virginia Supreme Court509
19599 S.E.2d 631In re Charity H.West Virginia Supreme Court478
20459 S.E.2d 329Williams v. Precision Coil, Inc.West Virginia Supreme Court464
21201 W. Va. 381Michael D.C. v. Wanda L.C.West Virginia Supreme Court455
22483 S.E.2d 12State Ex Rel. Hoover v. BergerWest Virginia Supreme Court453
23466 U.S. 668Strickland v. WashingtonU.S. Supreme Court445
24778 S.E.2d 338In Re M.M., B.M., C.Z., and C.SWest Virginia Supreme Court423
25219 S.E.2d 361Smith v. State Workmen's Compensation CommissionerWest Virginia Supreme Court419
26607 S.E.2d 803Carr v. HancockWest Virginia Supreme Court412
27169 W. Va. 366State v. GoodnightWest Virginia Supreme Court411
28905 S.E.2d 528Syl. Pt. 2, Duff v. Kanawha Cnty. Comm’nOther courts, cited401
29250 W. Va. 510Syl. Pt. 2, Duff v. Kanawha Cnty. Comm’nWest Virginia, cited but not in the corpus378
30466 S.E.2d 424Appalachian Power Co. v. State Tax DepartmentWest Virginia Supreme Court364
31194 W. Va. 446In Re Christina L.West Virginia Supreme Court341
32496 S.E.2d 221State v. LucasWest Virginia Supreme Court338
33435 S.E.2d 162In Re Jeffrey R.L.West Virginia Supreme Court332
34540 S.E.2d 542In Re Emily B.West Virginia Supreme Court332
35277 S.E.2d 606Losh v. McKenzieWest Virginia Supreme Court327
36196 W. Va. 442In Re QueenWest Virginia Supreme Court324
3765 S.E.2d 488State v. EpperlyWest Virginia Supreme Court323
38573 S.E.2d 354In re Tonjia M.West Virginia Supreme Court321
39203 S.E.2d 445State v. ThomasWest Virginia Supreme Court320
40156 W. Va. 467Perdue v. CoinerWest Virginia Supreme Court315
41408 S.E.2d 400James M. v. MaynardWest Virginia Supreme Court313
42107 S.E.2d 353State v. General Daniel Morgan Post No. 548West Virginia Supreme Court298
43558 S.E.2d 620In Re Edward B.West Virginia Supreme Court283
44384 U.S. 436Miranda v. ArizonaU.S. Supreme Court273
45201 W. Va. 108Walker v. West Virginia Ethics Commission.West Virginia Supreme Court272
46504 S.E.2d 177State v. Michael M.West Virginia Supreme Court265
47408 S.E.2d 365In the Interest of Carlita B.West Virginia Supreme Court260
48736 S.E.2d 80Justice v. West Virginia Office Insurance CommissionWest Virginia Supreme Court254
49902 S.E.2d 185Syl. Pt. 2, Christopher P. v. Amanda C.Other courts, cited252
50250 W. Va. 53Syl. Pt. 2, Christopher P. v. Amanda C.West Virginia, cited but not in the corpus250
51196 W. Va. 588Muscatell v. ClineWest Virginia Supreme Court249
52194 W. Va. 97Tennant v. Marion Health Care Foundation, Inc.West Virginia Supreme Court248
53679 S.E.2d 650Noble v. West Virginia Department of Motor VehiclesWest Virginia Supreme Court245
54469 S.E.2d 114Burgess v. PorterfieldWest Virginia Supreme Court243
55152 W. Va. 571State v. ElderWest Virginia Supreme Court242
56207 W. Va. 640State v. VanceWest Virginia Supreme Court242
57701 S.E.2d 97STATE EX REL. FRANKLIN v. McBrideWest Virginia Supreme Court230
58172 S.E.2d 698Barnett v. State Workmen's Compensation CommissionerWest Virginia Supreme Court227
59195 W. Va. 297Martin v. Randolph County Board of EducationWest Virginia Supreme Court225
60461 S.E.2d 101State v. LillyWest Virginia Supreme Court224
61524 S.E.2d 688Shaffer v. Acme Limestone Co., Inc.West Virginia Supreme Court224
62198 W. Va. 298State v. HeadWest Virginia Supreme Court221
63170 S.E.2d 367State Ex Rel. Kucera v. City of WheelingWest Virginia Supreme Court215
64356 S.E.2d 181State Ex Rel. W.Va. Department of Human Services v. Cheryl M.West Virginia Supreme Court215
65196 W. Va. 535Banker v. BankerWest Virginia Supreme Court212
66451 S.E.2d 731State v. DerrWest Virginia Supreme Court210
67276 S.E.2d 205Wanstreet v. BordenkircherWest Virginia Supreme Court206
68480 S.E.2d 538Public Citizen, Inc. v. First National Bank in FairmontWest Virginia Supreme Court206
69233 S.E.2d 425State Ex Rel. Peacher v. SencindiverWest Virginia Supreme Court205
70470 S.E.2d 162State Ex Rel. Cooper v. CapertonWest Virginia Supreme Court204
71193 W. Va. 229McDougal v. McCammonWest Virginia Supreme Court203
72236 S.E.2d 207Chapman v. Kane Transfer Co., Inc.West Virginia Supreme Court202
73204 W. Va. 58State v. RodoussakisWest Virginia Supreme Court202
74775 S.E.2d 458Gary E. Hammons v. W. Va. Ofc. of Insurance Comm./A & R Transport, etc.West Virginia Supreme Court202
75168 W. Va. 366In the Interest of S. C.West Virginia Supreme Court200
76244 S.E.2d 219State v. StarkeyWest Virginia Supreme Court197
77455 S.E.2d 516State v. McGinnisWest Virginia Supreme Court193
78207 S.E.2d 129In Re WillisWest Virginia Supreme Court188
79476 S.E.2d 535State v. MillerWest Virginia Supreme Court187
80172 S.E.2d 384Crockett v. AndrewsWest Virginia Supreme Court184
81227 W. Va. 330Davies v. Wv Office of the Insurance Commission, 35550 (w.va. 4-1-2011)West Virginia Supreme Court184
82188 W. Va. 197Lieving v. HadleyWest Virginia Supreme Court183
83195 W. Va. 314State Ex Rel. Daniel v. LegurskyWest Virginia Supreme Court182
84300 S.E.2d 86Nelson v. West Virginia Public Employees Insurance BoardWest Virginia Supreme Court181
85195 W. Va. 759State, Department of Health & Human Resources Ex Rel. Robert Michael B. v. Robert Morris N.West Virginia Supreme Court180
86225 S.E.2d 218Sanders v. Georgia-Pacific Corp.West Virginia Supreme Court178
87421 S.E.2d 247Andrick v. Town of BuckhannonWest Virginia Supreme Court178
88262 S.E.2d 744Hinkle v. BlackWest Virginia Supreme Court177
89149 W. Va. 246Barnett v. WolfolkWest Virginia Supreme Court174
90327 S.E.2d 671Committee on Legal Ethics of West Virginia State Bar v. BlairWest Virginia Supreme Court174
91470 S.E.2d 205State Ex Rel. Amy M. v. KaufmanWest Virginia Supreme Court174
92562 S.E.2d 147In Re Daniel D.West Virginia Supreme Court174
93882 S.E.2d 916David Duff, II v. Kanawha County CommissionIntermediate Court of Appeals of West Virginia173
94309 S.E.2d 342Shepherdstown Volunteer Fire Dept. v. State Ex Rel. State Human Rights CommissionWest Virginia Supreme Court172
95466 S.E.2d 171Gentry v. MangumWest Virginia Supreme Court171
96204 W. Va. 430Wickland v. American Travellers Life InsuranceWest Virginia Supreme Court170
97474 S.E.2d 872Powderidge Unit Owners Ass'n v. Highland Properties, Ltd.West Virginia Supreme Court169
98729 S.E.2d 231Tudor's Biscuit World of America v. CritchleyWest Virginia Supreme Court169
99787 S.E.2d 864Samuel Anstey v. David Ballard, WardenWest Virginia Supreme Court169
100233 W. Va. 57In Re B.H. and S.SWest Virginia Supreme Court167

Built from the caselaw set; each case links its record on CourtListener.

Most-citing courts

Each West Virginia court's opinions in the corpus, by citations made.

CourtCasesCitations madeMedian per caseTimes its cases are cited
West Virginia Supreme Court32,922373,8458244,966
Intermediate Court of Appeals of West Virginia1,44011,2616749

Built from the caselaw set.

Citation depth by decade

Cases by decade decided: how many authorities each cites, how old they are and where they come from.

DecadeCasesMedian citations found in the textMedian citesMedian cites, opinions over 5,000 charactersShort orders, under 2,000 characters90th percentileMedian age of cited case, yearsCite the U.S. Supreme CourtCite other courtsMedian times citedResolved by
1860s18710111%315.3%38.5%3table 70%, citation only 25%, pin page 4%, other 0%
1870s6812236%11311.7%62.1%4table 66%, citation only 27%, pin page 5%, other 2%
1880s1,0807661%22524.1%74.4%8table 77%, citation only 14%, pin page 7%, other 1%
1890s1,2328662%19822.9%67.5%7table 84%, citation only 8%, pin page 6%, other 2%
1900s1,5979782%221126.2%64.9%6table 90%, citation only 4%, pin page 4%, other 1%
1910s2,1867772%191316.8%61.3%4table 92%, pin page 3%, citation only 3%, other 1%
1920s2,5387661%161313.8%56.3%3table 94%, pin page 2%, citation only 2%, other 1%
1930s2,0647462%151512.7%49.8%2table 97%, other 3%
1940s99617990%282218.0%55.4%6table 98%, other 2%
1950s7943317170%482620.7%68.1%7table 97%, other 3%
1960s7772713141%432122.4%58.7%9table 97%, other 3%
1970s1,0832010111%291736.4%52.9%9table 97%, other 3%
1980s2,4422312130%42840.2%51.5%6table 97%, other 3%
1990s2,5652412120%35935.5%42.3%5table 97%, other 3%
2000s1,6212814140%391333.8%43.4%4table 97%, other 3%
2010s7,14812660%201918.2%15.0%0table 96%, other 4%
2020s5,37114880%202415.2%50.0%0table 80%, citation only 14%, docket 3%, other 3%

"Median cites" counts the authorities in the graph each case cites; "Citations found in the text" counts citation strings, so a case printed in two reporters counts twice there. Short orders that cite nothing pull the medians down, so the table also gives the median for opinions over 5,000 characters.

Spot check of this build: 299 of 300 citations confirmed against the printed name, citation or docket (99.7%). Wrong citations: 0 of the 200 most cited and 0 of 500 random cases, against 0 of 198 and 0 of 500 in the graph it replaced.

Built from the caselaw set.

Citations by method

Each citation and the method that found its case.

MethodCitationsShare
Reporter citation in CourtListener's table357,31992.8%
Citation only, no case found15,1263.9%
Statute or rule3,4740.9%
Pin page3,3070.9%
Docket number2,1370.6%
Parallel citation learned from the corpus1,4730.4%
Shared page decided by the printed name1,3780.4%
Case name, court and year6970.2%
Short form1040.0%
Westlaw or Lexis citation910.0%

Built from the caselaw set.

How often cases are cited

Cases in the corpus by the number of West Virginia cases that cite them.

Cited byCases
012,547
13,438
2 to 46,198
5 to 95,570
10 to 496,091
50 to 99345
100 or more173

Built from the caselaw set.

Most-cited statutes and rules

Statutes and rules by the number of West Virginia cases citing them.

Statute or ruleCited by
42 U.S.C. § 1983112
U.S. Const. amend. V91
U.S. Const. amend. XIV89
U.S. Const. amend. VI73
9 U.S.C. § 249
U.S. Const. art. I44
U.S. Const. amend. IV39
9 U.S.C. § 135
42 U.S.C. § 2000e35
U.S. Const. art. VI30
11 U.S.C. § 36226
45 U.S.C. § 5126
42 U.S.C. § 1210125
U.S. Const. amend. VIII24
30 U.S.C. § 120120

Built from the caselaw set.

Method

Built from 39,779 opinions: 715,894 citations went to one case in the citation table and 4,201 to statutes and rules.

Change since the previous build (2026-11-13, extractor precedent-1.7): +290 nodes, +2,027 edges.

Each step is on the method page. The citation table is CourtListener's citations file.

Data

How to cite this graph, and its terms.

2,000 case pages (list), all under the site terms. Cite as: Repleader, https://repleader.net/precedent/wv/, data through . Agents: the free MCP tools answer the same questions.

All states: state knowledge graphs.

Related: federal civil filings in West Virginia, citation lookup, how the site counts, corrections, the data API.

Built from the caselaw set and CourtListener's citation table.