Valley Circle Estates v. VTN Consolidated, Inc., 33 Cal. 3d 604, is cited by 49 California cases in the California knowledge graph, rank 8,758 of 391,247 by times cited.

Valley Circle Estates v. VTN Consolidated, Inc., 33 Cal. 3d 604 (1983)

As of , data through , built .

California Supreme Court, decided . In the California knowledge graph, decisions through . Parallel citations: 189 Cal. Rptr. 871; 1983 Cal. LEXIS 167; 659 P.2d 1160.

Later treatment

What later California opinions said about this case in words.

Through 2026-09-29, no later California opinion in the corpus says in words that this case was overruled, questioned or limited. This is not a finding that the case is good law.

Treatment labels report what later opinions said in words; they do not read your facts or say whether a case binds a court.

Treatment as of any date, for many citations at once: validity records in the Legal AI API.

Source: the opinion on CourtListener.

In the California knowledge graph

Times cited, rank and citations made.

Cited by
49

California cases, each counted once

Rank by times cited
8,758

of 391,247 cases in the graph

PageRank rank
14,695

of 421,556 authorities

Cites
37

authorities in the graph

Citation group
2

64,486 cases

An edge means the opinion's text cites that authority. It does not mean the opinion relied on, followed or agreed with it.

Graph build of . Source: CourtListener record.

Cases that cite it

The California cases that cite it, ranked by PageRank.

Overruled
0
Questioned
0
Distinguished
0
Followed
1
Cited
48
Not labeled
0

Each label is read from the citing sentence. "Cited" means no stronger signal; "not labeled" means a dissent, a concurrence or a passage not read.

Citing caseCitationCourtYearTreatment
Tech-Bilt, Inc. v. Woodward-Clyde & Associates38 Cal. 3d 488California Supreme Court1985Cited
Gutierrez v. Mofid39 Cal. 3d 892California Supreme Court1985Cited
People v. Cicero157 Cal. App. 3d 465California Court of Appeal1984Cited
Lantzy v. Centex Homes31 Cal. 4th 363California Supreme Court2003Followed
Crouse v. Brobeck, Phleger & Harrison67 Cal. App. 4th 1509California Court of Appeal1998Cited
Mangini v. Aerojet-General Corp.230 Cal. App. 3d 1125California Court of Appeal1991Cited
Hittle v. Santa Barbara County Employees Retirement Ass'n39 Cal. 3d 374California Supreme Court1985Cited
Milligan v. City of Laguna Beach34 Cal. 3d 829California Supreme Court1983Cited
Bernson v. Browning-Ferris Industries of California, Inc.7 Cal. 4th 926California Supreme Court1994Cited
Watts v. Crawford10 Cal. 4th 743California Supreme Court1995Cited
GEM Developers v. Hallcraft Homes of San Diego, Inc.213 Cal. App. 3d 419California Court of Appeal1989Cited
Coombs v. Pierce1 Cal. App. 4th 568California Court of Appeal1991Cited
La Jolla Village Homeowners' Ass'n v. Superior Court212 Cal. App. 3d 1131California Court of Appeal1989Cited
City of Ontario v. Superior Court12 Cal. App. 4th 894California Court of Appeal1993Cited
City of San Diego v. United States Gypsum Co.30 Cal. App. 4th 575California Court of Appeal1994Cited
Moseley v. Abrams170 Cal. App. 3d 355California Court of Appeal1985Cited
Rubenstein v. Doe No. 13 Cal. 5th 903California Supreme Court2017Cited
Prudential Home Mortg. Co. v. Superior Court of Orange Cty.66 Cal. App. 4th 1236California Court of Appeal1998Cited
Bradley v. Breen73 Cal. App. 4th 798California Court of Appeal1999Cited
West v. Superior Court27 Cal. App. 4th 1625California Court of Appeal1994Cited
Rodrigues v. Superior Court127 Cal. App. 4th 1027California Court of Appeal2005Cited
Industrial Risk Insurers v. the Rust Engineering Co.232 Cal. App. 3d 1038California Court of Appeal1991Cited
Grange Debris Box & Wrecking Co. v. SUPERIOR COURT OF MARIN CTY.16 Cal. App. 4th 1349California Court of Appeal1993Cited
Postley v. Harvey153 Cal. App. 3d 280California Court of Appeal1984Cited
Cal. Rifle & Pistol Ass'n v. City of West Hollywood66 Cal. App. 4th 1302California Court of Appeal1998Cited

Source: CourtListener record.

Treatment by citing opinions

Citing opinions whose sentence followed, distinguished, questioned or overruled it, most severe first.

TreatmentCiting caseCitationCourtYear
FollowedLantzy v. Centex Homes31 Cal. 4th 363California Supreme Court2003

Each label is read from one sentence; read the opinion. Source: CourtListener record.

What it cites

The most-cited of the authorities its opinion cites, by how often California cases cite them.

AuthorityCitationCourt or groupYearCited by
American Motorcycle Assn. v. Superior Court20 Cal. 3d 578California Supreme Court1978305
People v. Knowles35 Cal. 2d 175California Supreme Court1950294
Babb v. Superior Court3 Cal. 3d 841California Supreme Court1971250
County of Los Angeles v. Frisbie19 Cal. 2d 634California Supreme Court1942153
Rossmoor Sanitation, Inc. v. Pylon, Inc.13 Cal. 3d 622California Supreme Court1975125
E. L. White, Inc. v. City of Huntington Beach21 Cal. 3d 497California Supreme Court1978113
People v. Chambers7 Cal. 3d 666California Supreme Court1972112
Pashley v. Pacific Electric Railway Co.25 Cal. 2d 226California Supreme Court194482
People v. Superior Court70 Cal. 2d 123California Supreme Court196979
Cossack v. City of Los Angeles11 Cal. 3d 726California Supreme Court197475
Regents of University of California v. Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co.21 Cal. 3d 624California Supreme Court197861
People Ex Rel. Department of Transportation v. Superior Court26 Cal. 3d 744California Supreme Court198056
Timberidge Enterprises, Inc. v. City of Santa Rosa86 Cal. App. 3d 873California Court of Appeal197839
Roylance v. Doelger57 Cal. 2d 255California Supreme Court196237
Watkins v. Real Estate Commissioner182 Cal. App. 2d 397California Court of Appeal196033
Neff v. New York Life Insurance30 Cal. 2d 165California Supreme Court194730
Liptak v. Diane Apartments, Inc.109 Cal. App. 3d 762California Court of Appeal198027
Martinez v. Traubner32 Cal. 3d 755California Supreme Court198221
Centinela Valley Secondary Teachers Ass'n v. Centinela Valley Union High School District37 Cal. App. 3d 35California Court of Appeal197419
People ex rel. Wood v. Sands102 Cal. 12California Supreme Court189415
Ocean Shore Railroad v. City of Santa Cruz198 Cal. App. 2d 267California Court of Appeal196115
Thorpe v. Story10 Cal. 2d 104California Supreme Court193713
Shepard & Morgan v. Lee & Daniel, Inc.31 Cal. 3d 256California Supreme Court198213
Zastrow v. Zastrow61 Cal. App. 3d 710California Court of Appeal197611
Jefferson Incorporated v. City of Torrance266 Cal. App. 2d 300California Court of Appeal196810

Source: CourtListener record.

Citation group

Cases that cite each other more than the rest of the graph: a statistical grouping, not a subject index.

This case is one of 64,486 cases in citation group 2 of the California graph. Its leading cases by PageRank:

  1. Denham v. Superior Court, 2 Cal. 3d 557 (1970)
  2. Aguilar v. Atlantic Richfield Co., 25 Cal. 4th 826 (2001)
  3. Blank v. Kirwan, 39 Cal. 3d 311 (1985)
  4. Palma v. U.S. Industrial Fasteners, Inc., 36 Cal. 3d 171 (1984)
  5. In Re Marriage of Flaherty, 31 Cal. 3d 637 (1982)

Built from CourtListener's citation table.

On the map

The California knowledge graph, opened at this case: what it cites and the most-cited cases that cite it.

It loads the state's map; or open it on the California page.

Data

Read and cite with a link; reuse needs a license.

Under the site terms. Cite as: Repleader, https://repleader.net/precedent/ca/case/1449430/, California knowledge graph, decisions through 2026-09-29. The opinion text is on CourtListener. Agents can ask the same questions through the free MCP tools (cases_citing, cited_by, validity, top_cited).

More: the California knowledge graph, citation lookup, every state, federal civil filings in California.