Valley Circle Estates v. VTN Consolidated, Inc., 33 Cal. 3d 604, is cited by 49 California cases in the California knowledge graph, rank 8,758 of 391,247 by times cited.
Valley Circle Estates v. VTN Consolidated, Inc., 33 Cal. 3d 604 (1983)
As of , data through , built .
California Supreme Court, decided . In the California knowledge graph, decisions through . Parallel citations: 189 Cal. Rptr. 871; 1983 Cal. LEXIS 167; 659 P.2d 1160.
Later treatment
What later California opinions said about this case in words.
Through 2026-09-29, no later California opinion in the corpus says in words that this case was overruled, questioned or limited. This is not a finding that the case is good law.
Treatment labels report what later opinions said in words; they do not read your facts or say whether a case binds a court.
Treatment as of any date, for many citations at once: validity records in the Legal AI API.
Source: the opinion on CourtListener.
In the California knowledge graph
Times cited, rank and citations made.
- Cited by
- 49
- Rank by times cited
- 8,758
- PageRank rank
- 14,695
- Cites
- 37
- Citation group
- 2
California cases, each counted once
of 391,247 cases in the graph
of 421,556 authorities
authorities in the graph
64,486 cases
An edge means the opinion's text cites that authority. It does not mean the opinion relied on, followed or agreed with it.
Graph build of . Source: CourtListener record.
Cases that cite it
The California cases that cite it, ranked by PageRank.
- Overruled
- 0
- Questioned
- 0
- Distinguished
- 0
- Followed
- 1
- Cited
- 48
- Not labeled
- 0
Each label is read from the citing sentence. "Cited" means no stronger signal; "not labeled" means a dissent, a concurrence or a passage not read.
| Citing case | Citation | Court | Year | Treatment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tech-Bilt, Inc. v. Woodward-Clyde & Associates | 38 Cal. 3d 488 | California Supreme Court | 1985 | Cited |
| Gutierrez v. Mofid | 39 Cal. 3d 892 | California Supreme Court | 1985 | Cited |
| People v. Cicero | 157 Cal. App. 3d 465 | California Court of Appeal | 1984 | Cited |
| Lantzy v. Centex Homes | 31 Cal. 4th 363 | California Supreme Court | 2003 | Followed |
| Crouse v. Brobeck, Phleger & Harrison | 67 Cal. App. 4th 1509 | California Court of Appeal | 1998 | Cited |
| Mangini v. Aerojet-General Corp. | 230 Cal. App. 3d 1125 | California Court of Appeal | 1991 | Cited |
| Hittle v. Santa Barbara County Employees Retirement Ass'n | 39 Cal. 3d 374 | California Supreme Court | 1985 | Cited |
| Milligan v. City of Laguna Beach | 34 Cal. 3d 829 | California Supreme Court | 1983 | Cited |
| Bernson v. Browning-Ferris Industries of California, Inc. | 7 Cal. 4th 926 | California Supreme Court | 1994 | Cited |
| Watts v. Crawford | 10 Cal. 4th 743 | California Supreme Court | 1995 | Cited |
| GEM Developers v. Hallcraft Homes of San Diego, Inc. | 213 Cal. App. 3d 419 | California Court of Appeal | 1989 | Cited |
| Coombs v. Pierce | 1 Cal. App. 4th 568 | California Court of Appeal | 1991 | Cited |
| La Jolla Village Homeowners' Ass'n v. Superior Court | 212 Cal. App. 3d 1131 | California Court of Appeal | 1989 | Cited |
| City of Ontario v. Superior Court | 12 Cal. App. 4th 894 | California Court of Appeal | 1993 | Cited |
| City of San Diego v. United States Gypsum Co. | 30 Cal. App. 4th 575 | California Court of Appeal | 1994 | Cited |
| Moseley v. Abrams | 170 Cal. App. 3d 355 | California Court of Appeal | 1985 | Cited |
| Rubenstein v. Doe No. 1 | 3 Cal. 5th 903 | California Supreme Court | 2017 | Cited |
| Prudential Home Mortg. Co. v. Superior Court of Orange Cty. | 66 Cal. App. 4th 1236 | California Court of Appeal | 1998 | Cited |
| Bradley v. Breen | 73 Cal. App. 4th 798 | California Court of Appeal | 1999 | Cited |
| West v. Superior Court | 27 Cal. App. 4th 1625 | California Court of Appeal | 1994 | Cited |
| Rodrigues v. Superior Court | 127 Cal. App. 4th 1027 | California Court of Appeal | 2005 | Cited |
| Industrial Risk Insurers v. the Rust Engineering Co. | 232 Cal. App. 3d 1038 | California Court of Appeal | 1991 | Cited |
| Grange Debris Box & Wrecking Co. v. SUPERIOR COURT OF MARIN CTY. | 16 Cal. App. 4th 1349 | California Court of Appeal | 1993 | Cited |
| Postley v. Harvey | 153 Cal. App. 3d 280 | California Court of Appeal | 1984 | Cited |
| Cal. Rifle & Pistol Ass'n v. City of West Hollywood | 66 Cal. App. 4th 1302 | California Court of Appeal | 1998 | Cited |
Source: CourtListener record.
Treatment by citing opinions
Citing opinions whose sentence followed, distinguished, questioned or overruled it, most severe first.
| Treatment | Citing case | Citation | Court | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Followed | Lantzy v. Centex Homes | 31 Cal. 4th 363 | California Supreme Court | 2003 |
Each label is read from one sentence; read the opinion. Source: CourtListener record.
What it cites
The most-cited of the authorities its opinion cites, by how often California cases cite them.
| Authority | Citation | Court or group | Year | Cited by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| American Motorcycle Assn. v. Superior Court | 20 Cal. 3d 578 | California Supreme Court | 1978 | 305 |
| People v. Knowles | 35 Cal. 2d 175 | California Supreme Court | 1950 | 294 |
| Babb v. Superior Court | 3 Cal. 3d 841 | California Supreme Court | 1971 | 250 |
| County of Los Angeles v. Frisbie | 19 Cal. 2d 634 | California Supreme Court | 1942 | 153 |
| Rossmoor Sanitation, Inc. v. Pylon, Inc. | 13 Cal. 3d 622 | California Supreme Court | 1975 | 125 |
| E. L. White, Inc. v. City of Huntington Beach | 21 Cal. 3d 497 | California Supreme Court | 1978 | 113 |
| People v. Chambers | 7 Cal. 3d 666 | California Supreme Court | 1972 | 112 |
| Pashley v. Pacific Electric Railway Co. | 25 Cal. 2d 226 | California Supreme Court | 1944 | 82 |
| People v. Superior Court | 70 Cal. 2d 123 | California Supreme Court | 1969 | 79 |
| Cossack v. City of Los Angeles | 11 Cal. 3d 726 | California Supreme Court | 1974 | 75 |
| Regents of University of California v. Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co. | 21 Cal. 3d 624 | California Supreme Court | 1978 | 61 |
| People Ex Rel. Department of Transportation v. Superior Court | 26 Cal. 3d 744 | California Supreme Court | 1980 | 56 |
| Timberidge Enterprises, Inc. v. City of Santa Rosa | 86 Cal. App. 3d 873 | California Court of Appeal | 1978 | 39 |
| Roylance v. Doelger | 57 Cal. 2d 255 | California Supreme Court | 1962 | 37 |
| Watkins v. Real Estate Commissioner | 182 Cal. App. 2d 397 | California Court of Appeal | 1960 | 33 |
| Neff v. New York Life Insurance | 30 Cal. 2d 165 | California Supreme Court | 1947 | 30 |
| Liptak v. Diane Apartments, Inc. | 109 Cal. App. 3d 762 | California Court of Appeal | 1980 | 27 |
| Martinez v. Traubner | 32 Cal. 3d 755 | California Supreme Court | 1982 | 21 |
| Centinela Valley Secondary Teachers Ass'n v. Centinela Valley Union High School District | 37 Cal. App. 3d 35 | California Court of Appeal | 1974 | 19 |
| People ex rel. Wood v. Sands | 102 Cal. 12 | California Supreme Court | 1894 | 15 |
| Ocean Shore Railroad v. City of Santa Cruz | 198 Cal. App. 2d 267 | California Court of Appeal | 1961 | 15 |
| Thorpe v. Story | 10 Cal. 2d 104 | California Supreme Court | 1937 | 13 |
| Shepard & Morgan v. Lee & Daniel, Inc. | 31 Cal. 3d 256 | California Supreme Court | 1982 | 13 |
| Zastrow v. Zastrow | 61 Cal. App. 3d 710 | California Court of Appeal | 1976 | 11 |
| Jefferson Incorporated v. City of Torrance | 266 Cal. App. 2d 300 | California Court of Appeal | 1968 | 10 |
Source: CourtListener record.
Citation group
Cases that cite each other more than the rest of the graph: a statistical grouping, not a subject index.
This case is one of 64,486 cases in citation group 2 of the California graph. Its leading cases by PageRank:
- Denham v. Superior Court, 2 Cal. 3d 557 (1970)
- Aguilar v. Atlantic Richfield Co., 25 Cal. 4th 826 (2001)
- Blank v. Kirwan, 39 Cal. 3d 311 (1985)
- Palma v. U.S. Industrial Fasteners, Inc., 36 Cal. 3d 171 (1984)
- In Re Marriage of Flaherty, 31 Cal. 3d 637 (1982)
Built from CourtListener's citation table.
On the map
The California knowledge graph, opened at this case: what it cites and the most-cited cases that cite it.
It loads the state's map; or open it on the California page.
The map needs JavaScript. Without it, its figures are in the tables here.
Data
Read and cite with a link; reuse needs a license.
Under the site terms. Cite as: Repleader, https://repleader.net/precedent/ca/case/1449430/, California knowledge graph, decisions through 2026-09-29. The opinion text is on CourtListener. Agents can ask the same questions through the free MCP tools (cases_citing, cited_by, validity, top_cited).
More: the California knowledge graph, citation lookup, every state, federal civil filings in California.